Should we stop making manual cars?

You don't still use a Nokia brick, so why are we still making manuals.

“Would you like a manual or an automatic?” asked the lady at Enterprise. And as I was heading northbound to the far tip of Scotland, I responded that I would like an automatic – giving me a little bit of leeway to focus on where I was going.

“Ok, that will be an extra £60 for the automatic.” I handed over my bank card and thought nothing of it until I was on the long winding road to the Highlands. Why are automatics always so much more expensive to buy or hire? I assume it is because manual cars have been around longer, so autos are just by default a bit more pricey. But then if you look at America, where over 95% drive automatics, that cannot be the reason.

Then I thought, it must be because of what the automatic offers: an easier and more relaxing experience for drivers. But then, why would the car rental company want to push people to manual cars they likely weren’t used to. And, surely with a manual, you’re actually getting more ‘car’ in the traditional sense, so why are they so much more?

Well, according to MoneySuperMarket, automatics tend to be more expensive because the parts are spenny and are a little bit complex. Where you can fix a manual with a wrench and two mugs of tea, automatics will need a Harley Street doctor when it’s poorly.

There’s a bigger question to ask here, though, and that’s why as a planet are we still making manual cars anyway?

We know for a fact that automatic cars are easier to drive, making them more accessible to a wider and diverse audience. Automatics are also arguably safer, as drivers have one fewer thing for the brain to focus on. Automatics are a lot more fuel-efficient than manuals, which is good for polar bears. And, in thirty years when all the oil is gone, we’ll be driving electrics anyway: which are all automatic.

I raised this with a friend recently and the reply I got back was ‘but a manual is proper driving isn’t it’. But that surely can’t be why we would keep producing manual cars.

When automation reached manufacturing, we didn’t all cry out ‘oh no, this isn’t how goods should be made, we should have women doing it in a bleak factory, and children should be munched by the machine, daily’.

And when Steve Jobs revolutionised the smartphone, we all shifted a gear, we did not long for the days of a Motorola brick and a half-metre antenna. So, why when we made huge progress developing the car have we kept its predecessor around.

The only reason I can think of is the price and it being cheaper to build a manual car. Which roughly translated means, rather than push forward the automatic car into new reaches, perhaps making them cheaper to make and easier to fix, manufacturers have dithered. But surely at some point they will have to call time on the manual. Why not now?

Join In

Comments (42)

  • Because...We don't mind iPhone over Nokia BUT we do mind iPhone when it does not having a fingerprint reading home button and a headphone jack. Manual is not "ancient", it's not so revolutionary in cars than say, having horses to tow the cart around.

    People can do anything on a laptop nowadays but some still keep TVs and Desktops around, Apple made a watch that can do all the calling and messaging but most still like to do those on an actual iPhone, voice input have been around for Years and is pretty good now and people still use a keyboard to Google stuff.

    Motorcycles also have had automatics for a while now, didn't saw that catch on.

    "The world have moved on" is only a statement true for those with no "habit" or "preference", or in other words, someone who wouldn't care less in the field of the topic. I wouldn't care whatever people put in my "full English breakfast", "I moved on from that".

      1 year ago
    • Yes but arguably all those technologies have been further developed. TVs are now smart. Voice AI increasingly just as important as keyboards etc. As you say though, sometimes new developments aren't welcome. All I'm saying is I think we...

      Read more
        1 year ago
    • Oh trust me Manuals have also been futher improved, the feeling when changing gear in a new 911 is not the same as changing gear in a 40s Beetle, the stick, the pedals, all different. Oh and there are more gears.

      People have already tried very...

      Read more
        1 year ago
  • High revving NA engines and a manual gearbox to give the real enjoyment and more importantly, the sense of theatre in driving down twisty roads.... Big SMILES

      1 year ago
  • No stick your auto cars manual all the way

      1 year ago
  • No

      1 year ago
  • No.

      1 year ago