Winners and losers: Karun's F1 2019 team-by-team verdict

Our Formula 1 expert takes a look at the winners and losers from the Grand Prix season

1y ago

Karun Chandhok is a former Formula 1 driver who is now an expert analyst and pundit for Sky Sports F1 and DriveTribe.


So there we go – the 2019 F1 championship has drawn to a close with Lewis Hamilton taking another victory and the two young pretenders to his crown standing alongside him at the final race.

It was a bit of an anti-climatic end to the season with a dull race in Abu Dhabi but unfortunately for the Yas Marina circuit it often is. The facilities and the atmosphere around the paddock and marina is sensational but as for the actual track layout, it really needs to be looked at for the future if it is to remain the championship decider.

The track design in Abu Dhabi needs a re-think

The track design in Abu Dhabi needs a re-think

There are a lot of negative-camber medium and slow speed corners which are very hard for the tyres and make it really tricky for the drivers to follow each other. It’s a bit of a shame that even the championship deciders we had here in 2010 and 2016 were tense and dramatic races because of the lack of overtaking (Fernando Alonso couldn’t pass Vitaly Petrov in 2010 and Nico Rosberg couldn’t pass Lewis in 2016).

Lewis and Mercedes were in a class of their own all weekend and once he got to the first corner first, there really was nothing anybody else could do to stop him. Max Verstappen did another strong race, finishing over 50 seconds ahead of Alex Albon showing that Red Bull really do rely on Max to deliver, while Ferrari have never gone particularly well around this circuit, especially in sector 3.

With the race being a bit uneventful, I thought it’s probably a good time to look back at the season as a whole and perhaps review the teams and drivers in brief.


Another vintage year for Mercedes

Another vintage year for Mercedes

Mercedes were unquestionably the best team as a package of competitiveness and operational strength across the 21 races. Lewis has been very good all year, especially on the Sundays. He shouldn’t have won races like Canada, Russia and Mexico but he was there to capitalise on errors from the opposition and the commanding wins in Spain and Silverstone, where despite being behind Valtteri Bottas on the grid, he turned the tables in his favour.

Valtteri had a better year than the last one where he seemed to fade as the season went on.

Bottas needs to find a way of beating Hamilton consistently if he is ever to win the world championship

Bottas needs to find a way of beating Hamilton consistently if he is ever to win the world championship

The victories in Japan and Austin showed that he was capable of hitting the highs he needs to beat Lewis, but in a very Barrichello/Schumacher sort of way, ie. a handful of times per season.

Like Rubens, Valtteri is up against the best driver of his generation so it will be a tall order to beat him across the year and he will have to dig really deep to do so.


Ferrari had another year of under-delivering on the whole. They looked brilliantly fast in pre-season testing but then we got to Melbourne and they were nowhere in comparison to Mercedes.

In 2017, Sebastian Vettel could have been champion, in 2018 he *should* have been champion, while this season, Charles Leclerc could at least have taken the battle to the final round.

Leclerc should have been a contender this year

Leclerc should have been a contender this year

When we add up all the errors, Leclerc should have arrived in Abu Dhabi just nine points behind Lewis and still in contention going into the last race.

To re-cap: in Bahrain Leclerc had the engine issue while leading comfortably and in China the team used him to strategically hold up the opposition to help Vettel but it cost Charles a couple of points. In Baku and Monaco Charles made errors in Qualifying and then crashed in Germany.

Vettel had a strangely sub-par season, winning just once

Vettel had a strangely sub-par season, winning just once

In Austria, Singapore and Mexico the team made poor strategic choices which cost Leclerc while Vettel’s error in Canada gave more points to Lewis. On the whole, Mercedes had a faster car than Ferrari for probably 75 per cent of the season but the Scuderia still underdelivered on what they had.

The Italian team were lucky that Red Bull’s second driver didn’t really match Max Verstappen’s scoring rate in the championship.

Red Bull-Honda

The Anglo-Austrian team seemed to be affected by the change in front wing regulations more than some others and did struggle at the start of the season. By the time we got to Austria, the championship challenge didn’t look like it was on the cards anymore but at least Verstappen was able to rack up three victories and secure third in the Championship ahead of both Ferrari drivers.

Max Verstappen had a good season – and will be looking to mount a serious title challenge in 2020

Max Verstappen had a good season – and will be looking to mount a serious title challenge in 2020

Honda looked like it made decent progress this season and despite both the Red Bulls and Toro Rossos taking grid penalties at various stages of the season, the reliability was a lot better than in previous years.

When you look at the qualifying comparisons, Pierre Gasly was on average 0.417 away from Max, whereas Albon was actually further away at 0.433. The problem for Gasly was that early on in the season, the Red Bull wasn’t as good a car and therefore he would often get caught up battling with the midfield runners in the opening part of the race and just not make enough progress.

Pierre Gasly had a difficult start to the season with Red Bull, before his move back to Toro Rosso

Pierre Gasly had a difficult start to the season with Red Bull, before his move back to Toro Rosso

Albon did seem to make progress in the races a bit better than Gasly, but considering the gap to Max, you have to wonder how much of that is the car now being a lot better than it was at the start of the year? Albon deserves another shot, but 2020 could be his last chance to hang on to a top seat so he’s got to make it count.


The midfield battle was as tight as ever this year. McLaren did an outstanding job over the winter to go from sometimes having the slowest car on track in 2018 to being the clear best of the rest in 2019.

McLaren are on the way back

McLaren are on the way back

It’s not often that we see such a turn-around from a team these days and it shows that if your fundamental concept is wrong, as it seemingly was in 2018, at some stage giving up on it and committing to a whole philosophical re-think can be very rewarding.

With Andreas Seidl and James Key leading the team, Zak Brown selling the dream to sponsors, two good drivers, a Mercedes engine deal in the offing and a new wind tunnel coming, they seem to now have the foundations in place to become a top team again in the next few years.

This was a breakout year for Carlos Sainz. Until now, we did wonder just how good he actually was but in 2019 he seemed to find a whole new level and establish himself as a true star of F1.

Carlos Sainz scored his first podium this year

Carlos Sainz scored his first podium this year

Lando Norris has clearly got great speed and his Qualifying performances were very impressive but his inexperience in the races showed sometimes. Carlos was able to put together better Sundays in general to get nearly twice as many points. The race performances will be better next year for Lando and the young Brit has been a breath of fresh air both in and out of the car this year.

And the rest

Renault, Haas and Williams will be disappointed with their seasons while Racing Point seemed to match their expectations in what is a year of transition for the team.

Alfa Romeo had an inconsistent season where they sometimes had no idea why a car that could get into Q3 one week, couldn’t even get out of Q1 the next.

Alfa Romeo struggled with inconsistency all year

Alfa Romeo struggled with inconsistency all year

Toro Rosso had some brilliant highs with the podiums in Hockenheim and Brazil and they will benefit from a stable driver line up for next season.

So there we have it, another year over and done with. Hope you’ve all enjoyed my columns this season and I look forward to bringing you more insights in 2020!

Join In

Comments (6)

  • I will be a bit Tifosi, I know, but if it was not for Vettel crashing into Leclerc at Brazil Charles would very likely be the 3rd in the championship overall: Their gap ended in 14 points. But if it was not for that accident Leclerc would have finished at least 3rd in Brazil, adding 15 points minimum.

      1 year ago
    • Honestly, does finishing third or fourth in the championship really make a difference?

        1 year ago
    • Little to none, but I still care about it 🤷🏻‍♂️

        1 year ago
  • Winners

    Mercedes were the big winner overall in my view.

    Mclaren most improved team off 2019

    Max Verstappen has improved as a driver despite a poor car.

    Hamiltion it hammer time every time he drives.

    Carlos Sainz JR did a good job with Mclaren this season.


    Ferrari underachived that simple needed an overhaul.

    Red Bull and Toro Rosso lack of result for both team put them in the lose group.

    Hass has a disappointing season needed to improve.


    Racing Point at times show potential with Perez and Stroll

    Alfa Romeo new team so i giving a season pass

    Renault in patches showed they can compete.

      1 year ago
  • Some brilliant races this year. Three midfield podiums, two of them in the same race!

    Really interesting fact about how Leclerc could have been just 9 points behind Hamilton. Heard you say it in commentary too.

      1 year ago
    • I missed that in comms, but it's amazing. And it shows how Ferrari really need to get their strategy/operational side sorted. Was embarrassing again on Saturday when Leclerc missed his last run in Q3

        1 year ago